Servers, Storage and Virtualization · #53
Online Virtualization TCO Comparison
Calculates cumulative totals and break-even time from one-off and annual costs of two options.
- Data is processed in your browser and not sent to a server
- Export: CSV
Tool
What does this tool do?
Looking only at the purchase price misleads server refresh, cloud migration or virtualization decisions: annual support, labour and energy can exceed the initial investment within a few years. The tool accumulates options A (current) and B (new) year by year and shows how many years the investment takes to pay back.
How to use it
- Enter the period (years) and currency.
- Enter one-off (licence, hardware, migration for B) and annual (support, labour, energy) costs for A and B; empty fields count as 0.
- Press Calculate; download the yearly table as CSV.
Fields
- Period (years)
- Currency
- Label only; no exchange rate is applied.
- A: licence (one-off)
- Current option.
- A: hardware (one-off)
- A: support (annual)
- A: labour (annual)
- A: energy (annual)
- B: licence (one-off)
- New option.
- B: hardware (one-off)
- B: migration (one-off)
- Project, training, parallel operation.
- B: support (annual)
- B: labour (annual)
- B: energy (annual)
Worked example
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Period (years) | 5 |
| Currency | EUR |
| A: support (annual) | 40000 |
| A: labour (annual) | 30000 |
| A: energy (annual) | 10000 |
| B: migration (one-off) | 120000 |
| B: support (annual) | 10000 |
| B: labour (annual) | 5000 |
| B: energy (annual) | 5000 |
Expected result: B's 120,000 migration cost pays back in 2 years with 60,000 annual savings; difference after 5 years 180,000 EUR.
Because break-even falls within the period, B can be preferred economically. Assess risks (migration downtime, lock-in, exchange rate) separately before deciding.
Second scenario
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Period (years) | 5 |
| Currency | USD |
| A: support (annual) | 18000 |
| A: labour (annual) | 12000 |
| B: hardware (one-off) | 90000 |
| B: migration (one-off) | 25000 |
| B: support (annual) | 9000 |
| B: labour (annual) | 6000 |
| B: energy (annual) | 4000 |
Expected result: A one-off investment of 115,000 USD in B pays back in ~10.5 years with 11,000 annual savings; not economical within 5 years.
Method and assumptions
Cumulative(y) = one-off + annual × y. Break-even = (B one-off − A one-off) / (A annual − B annual). Amounts are nominal; no inflation, discounting or exchange rates.
Using the result and troubleshooting
Set the period to the economic life of the hardware (usually 5 years). Without annual savings, decide on grounds such as risk reduction or new capabilities.
Limits and common mistakes
- Time value of money (NPV/IRR), tax, depreciation and residual value are not calculated.
Frequently asked questions
Should the current system cost be zero?
No. Maintenance, support extensions, energy and staff for the current system are A's annual costs; postponing a refresh is also a cost.
Related tools and service
- Server Consolidation PlannerTurns a physical server inventory into virtual requirements (vCPU, RAM, disk, host count).
Related service: Hardware Consulting